Laurel Kagay said Brad Womack popped the question to her before going on The Bachelor. He said reports of a marriage proposal were just "embellishment."
So who's telling the truth?
One of her friends, furious at Brad's "lies" and his decision to paint Laurel as "some crazy who invented it all in her head," wants to set the record straight.
Whether he proposed or not, Brad dated Laurel for years.
"If Brad Womack didn't propose to Laurel Kagay then I'm the Queen of England," Laurel's pal wrote in a series of scathing posts on her personal blog.
In one text message to his sweetheart, which Laurel Kagay shared with Us, Womack vowed: "You're my future, Roo. Nothing is going to change that.
"Laurel, I'm serious about this. Please marry me?"
The friend said Brad even took Laurel ring shopping at a Cartier boutique - and even asked her parents for their blessing to marry their daughter!
"Then the way he totally denied their relationship, basically demeaning it to nothing. I'm sorry, Brad, but you have officially p*ssed me off."
Of course, even if Brad did propose, she didn't say yes, we're guessing. His feelings for Chantal/Emily/Ashley aren't necessarily fake, either.
See The Bachelor spoilers here to see who he picks. Supposedly. Even the most trusted sources are wrong sometimes. But we doubt it here.